The Catholic Wisdom Behind Our Coaching
Hundreds of Years of Wisdom on Dating
24 Sources That Shape Everything We Teach
Most Catholic dating advice falls into one of two traps.
Trap one: pure theology. Beautiful, true, and completely useless when you’re sitting across from someone on a first date wondering if they’re marriage material. Trap two: secular dating tips with a Bible verse taped on. Practical, maybe, but hollow — because it doesn’t account for who you actually are.
Katie and I built Finding Adam Finding Eve because we got caught in both traps. I spent my twenties making bad choices with no formation. Katie spent hers trying to hold together a marriage that was falling apart. We had to learn the hard way that good intentions aren’t enough — you need a foundation.
By the end of this article, you’ll know every source that powers our coaching system, our Before Forever high school program, and the Game of Love app — and why each one matters for your life right now.
This is a pillar article. Over the coming weeks, we’ll publish individual deep dives on each of these 24 sources:
And 19 more — from Canon Law to the document that unlocked the Feminine Genius.
Why 24 Sources?
Because you were created for more than a swipe-and-ghost cycle. And the Church has spent two thousand years thinking about what love actually is, what goes wrong with it, and how it gets healed.
That’s the arc: created, fallen, redeemed. You were designed for communion. Sin and cultural confusion have distorted the design. Christ makes restoration possible. Every source in our system speaks to some part of that story.
I worked with a guy I’ll call James — 28, Catholic, frustrated. He’d read Theology of the Body and thought he was formed. But when it came to actual relationships, he kept freezing up. Couldn’t read signals. Couldn’t set boundaries. Couldn’t figure out why he kept attracting women who weren’t ready for commitment.
His theology was solid. His formation had gaps the size of a canyon.
That’s why we don’t just use one book or one document. We use 24 sources — 15,477 searchable passages — because formation isn’t a single lesson. It’s a system.
The Foundations
Catechism of the Catholic Church
The playbook. All 2,865 paragraphs, covering everything from the sacrament of marriage (CCC 1601-1666) to the vocation to chastity (CCC 2337-2359). When someone asks “what does the Church actually teach about X?” — this is where we start. Read more →
Sacred Scripture (Catholic Public Domain Version)
All 73 books of the Catholic canon. Not just the verses you’ve heard in homilies — the full sweep of salvation history that shows what covenantal love looks like in practice. Read more →
Summa Theologica
St. Thomas Aquinas spent nine years writing a comprehensive treatment of love, virtue, and human nature that the Church still relies on 750 years later. When we need to understand why the Church teaches what she teaches — the philosophical reasoning beneath the doctrine — we go to Thomas. Read more →
Theology of the Body
129 teaching sessions from John Paul II on God’s plan for human sexuality, the body, and marriage. This is the Church’s most complete treatment of relationships. It’s also widely misread — most people think it’s only about sex. It’s about the meaning of being a person. Read more →
The Family Documents
Familiaris Consortio (1981)
JP2’s blueprint for the Christian family. Marriage preparation, conjugal love, responsible parenthood, the family’s mission in the Church. If you want to know what you’re building toward, start here. Read more →
Amoris Laetitia (2016)
Pope Francis on the joy and mess of love in families. Pastoral, practical, honest about how hard family life can be. Read more →
Gratissimam Sane (1994)
JP2’s love letter to families — the nuptial meaning of the body, responsible parenthood, education. One of the least-known family documents in the magisterium, and one of the best. Read more →
Casti Connubii (1930)
Written by Pius XI almost a century ago, and it still gets marriage right. The nature and dignity of the marital bond, the blessings and duties of married life. This one proves the Church wasn’t making things up as she went along. Read more →
The Person Documents
Mulieris Dignitatem (1988)
The document that gave us the language of the Feminine Genius — receptivity, sensitivity, generosity, maternity. If you want to understand complementarity without falling into either feminism-as-erasure-of-difference or rigid gender roles, this is where you start. Read more →
Redemptoris Custos (1989)
St. Joseph as model of masculine virtue — initiative, protection, servant leadership, total self-gift. If Mulieris Dignitatem unlocks the feminine genius, Redemptoris Custos does the same for men. Read more →
Christus Vivit (2019)
Pope Francis wrote this directly to young people. Vocation, discernment, accompaniment, and the call to holiness in young adulthood. For our Before Forever teens and True Love young adults, this is the most directly addressed document in the collection. Read more →
Deus Caritas Est (2005)
Benedict XVI’s first encyclical. What does “God is love” actually mean? He unpacks eros and agape — desire and self-gift — and shows how they aren’t opposites but two dimensions of one love. Required reading for anyone who thinks the Church is against passion. Read more →
The Moral Framework
Veritatis Splendor (1993)
Freedom, law, conscience, and the relationship between faith and morality. When someone says “the Church just makes rules to control people,” this document is the answer. Moral truth isn’t restriction — it’s the condition for authentic freedom. Read more →
Evangelium Vitae (1995)
The Gospel of Life — human dignity, the inviolability of life, the culture of life versus the culture of death. This reframes dating itself: you’re not just choosing a partner, you’re choosing which culture you’ll build your family in. Read more →
The Truth and Meaning of Human Sexuality (1995)
Guidelines for parents and educators on forming young people in sexuality. This document is the backbone of our Before Forever parent formation component — and almost nobody knows it exists. Read more →
The Church’s Self-Understanding
Gaudium et Spes (1965)
The Church in the modern world. Paragraphs 48-52 contain essential marriage teaching. But the broader vision matters too — human dignity, community, culture, and the loneliness of modern life. Read more →
Lumen Gentium (1964)
You’re not dating alone. You belong to a people. The universal call to holiness applies to your love life. Read more →
Dei Verbum (1965)
How God reveals himself — through Scripture, Tradition, and the living teaching office of the Church. Understanding revelation matters because it’s the reason we can trust these sources in the first place. Read more →
Sacrosanctum Concilium (1963)
The liturgy as school of self-gift. Every Mass rehearses the pattern marriage requires: offering yourself completely, receiving the other, being transformed by the encounter. Read more →
Gravissimum Educationis (1965)
The Church’s vision for education — parents as primary educators, the role of Catholic schools, formation in faith and morals. The theological foundation for why our Before Forever program exists. Read more →
The Structural Sources
Code of Canon Law (1983)
Marriage requirements, impediments, annulment processes, sacramental preparation. When you need to know what the Church requires — not just recommends — for valid marriage, Canon Law provides the answer. Read more →
General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM)
How the Mass is celebrated and why each element matters. Understanding liturgy is understanding the pattern of self-gift that marriage mirrors. Read more →
The Applied Sources
FAFE Ministry Content
Ten years of real-world ministry — practical guides on boundaries, red flags, green flags, dating apps, attachment healing, communication, and conflict resolution. Church documents are true and beautiful. But sometimes you need someone to tell you what a healthy third date looks like. Read more →
Catholic Christian Meta-Model of the Person (CCMMP)
The framework from Divine Mercy University that integrates Catholic anthropology with psychology. This is the lens Katie trained in — 26 chapters on understanding the human person as body, soul, and spirit. It’s why our coaching doesn’t separate faith from psychology or healing from holiness. Read more →
How It All Works Together
These 24 sources live in our RAG system — 15,477 searchable passages that power the Game of Love virtual coach, inform every blog article we write, ground our Before Forever curriculum for high school students, and shape every coaching session Katie runs.
James — the 28-year-old I mentioned — came back six months later. He’d worked through our system. The Catechism gave him clarity on what marriage is ordered toward. Theology of the Body helped him understand his own desire. The CCMMP framework helped him see how his attachment wounds (that’s the fallen part of the story) were driving his patterns. And FAFE’s practical guides gave him the tools to actually change his behavior.
Theology without application sits on a shelf. Application without theology is just another self-help book. We built a system that holds both together — because that’s what redemption looks like in practice.
Your Turn
Pick one source from this list that you’ve never read. Just one. Read its individual article when it publishes. See how two thousand years of wisdom speaks to where you are right now.
You have the entire Catholic intellectual tradition behind you. Use it.
In Service,
Mike
Mike Palitto is co-founder of Finding Adam Finding Eve ministry and co-creator of the Game of Love app. Learn more at gameof.love.
Subscribe to our newsletter for weekly encouragement from Katie — newsletter.findingadamfindingeve.com
Take the free AdamEve Matrix Assessment → gameof.love
FAQ
Q: What sources does Finding Adam Finding Eve use for Catholic dating coaching? A: FAFE’s coaching system draws from 24 authoritative Catholic sources including the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Sacred Scripture, Theology of the Body, papal encyclicals like Familiaris Consortio and Mulieris Dignitatem, the Summa Theologica, Vatican II documents, Canon Law, and the Catholic Christian Meta-Model of the Person. These 15,477 searchable passages power the Game of Love virtual coach and all FAFE programs.
Q: How does Catholic teaching apply to modern dating? A: Catholic teaching provides a framework for understanding love, relationships, and human sexuality that addresses modern challenges like dating app burnout, attachment wounds, and the hookup culture. Documents like Theology of the Body explain the meaning of the body and desire, while practical ministry content bridges theology to real-world dating decisions like setting boundaries and recognizing red flags.
Q: What is the difference between Catholic dating coaching and secular dating advice? A: Catholic dating coaching integrates the Church’s understanding of the human person — created with dignity, wounded by sin, and called to redemption — with evidence-based psychology and practical relationship skills. Rather than treating dating as a technique to master, Catholic coaching frames it as vocational discernment grounded in virtue formation, self-knowledge, and authentic self-gift.